Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) ★★★★★ Criterion Theatre | Apr 4 - Aug 31, 2024


She's a rather cynical, world weary New Yorker. He's a naïve, overly enthusiastic Brit. They are brought together by his father's wedding to her sister, and they have nothing in common except the capacity for some extremely amusing barbs and banter. We all know how this is going to end, but the fun is in the emotional journey and its satisfyingly comfortable conclusion. Not surprisingly, it turns out that his relentless optimism and her wary skepticism both mask disappointments and losses which they will come to terms with as they carry their shared burden across the Big Apple and come to know each other. This is a delightful two-hander that is intended as a romcom for millennials, but like all representatives of the genre it ultimately depends on the chemistry of its principals. Both Sam Tutty as Dougal and Dujonna Gift as Robin bring their A-game to these performances. They are immediately likeable, and we are instantly rooting for them. Tutty exudes a puppy-like charm and energy. His moves are slick and his voice in a song like "Dad" is compelling. Gift is sharp without being off-putting, and she brings a sweetly plaintive quality to her solo "What'll It Be?" Her interpretation of "Be Happy" and "He Doesn't Exist" are quite exceptional moments. The many clever duets work well, and "Under the Mistletoe" is a wonderfully wacky tune. You may never hear Xmas songs in quite the same way again! If we have any quibble with the show, it is around the rather truncated revelation of Robin's falling out with her family, and Dougal's processing of that information. This complex dramatic point seems rather under-addressed and almost too facilely resolved. Nevertheless, Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) is an extremely entertaining iteration of the ageless genre that never fails to please, and in this instance, its two stars put in absolutely luminous performances.

Rated: ★★★★★

Reviewed by J.C.
Photo by Tristram Kenton

Want to save on tickets? See our Tips page.

When, Where, Getting there:
Map & Location: 218-223 Piccadilly, St. James's, London W1J 9HR, UK

Most Popular

Savage ★★ White Bear Theatre | Feb 25 - Mar 15, 2026

Image
Savage confronts a historically shocking and distressingly contemporary issue: the targeting of homosexual men with conversion therapy. The play recounts the horrific experiments carried out under the Nazi regime in Denmark to "cure" homosexuality and tells the true story of Dr Vaernet, who collaborated with Hitler’s regime in the belief that sexual orientation could be changed. This historical reality is dramatised through the story of Nikolai, a young Danish man, and his American lover, Zack. While Zack manages to escape the Nazi experiments, Nikolai endures them. Regrettably, this crucial historical legacy is presented simplistically and didactically. The characters are one-dimensional, and the plot is entirely predictable. The revelation that the Nazi persecutor of Nikolai is himself gay is unsurprising. It is almost a cliché that much homophobia is driven by repression of one’s own desires.The play’s simplistic characterisation is exacerbated by the production. Despite ...
Full Details »

St. Martin in-the-fields: Lunchtime Concerts ★★★★ FREE

Image
Maybe the best musical value in London. The lunchtime concerts at St. Martin's are always a wonderful way to escape the hustle and bustle that is London and the sensory overload that is Trafalgar Square. This is a beautiful setting with great acoustics, and a church pew hard enough to make sure you don't nod off. Reviewed by J.C.  Our score:    ☆☆☆☆  WHEN, WHERE, GETTING THERE: Mon & Fri: 1 pm - 1:45 pm ( occasionally Tues & Thurs)  St. Martin in-the-fields, Trafalgar Square Nearest tube: Charing Cross https://www.stmartin-in-the-fields.org/whats-on
Full Details »

The Holy Rosenbergs ★★★★★ Menier Chocolate Factory | Feb 27 - May 2, 2026

Image
In 2011, Ryan Craig wrote a play about the first Gaza war of 2009. The work carries an even deeper resonance in today’s fraught political climate. David Rosenberg once ran a successful Jewish catering business, but he has fallen on hard times after a rumour spread through the neighbourhood that his food caused a woman’s death by food poisoning. His wife Lesley believes they should leave the area that has now turned its back on them, but David is determined to restore his reputation. The fact that their son died defending Israel is seen as a way of re-establishing the family’s standing among those around them. Yet their daughter’s involvement in an inquiry that may bring charges against the Jewish state for its conduct during the 2009 Gaza war threatens this fragile hope of acceptance. The family’s predicament becomes a microcosm of a larger dilemma. At what point do the rewards of belonging to a family, a community, or a nation demand a loyalty that endangers personal integrity, and ho...
Full Details »

Mary, Queen of Scots ★★★★★ Sadler's Wells Theatre | March 5 - 8, 2026

Image
In 2019, to celebrate its 50th-anniversary season, Scottish Ballet commissioned five new works. The fifth and final of these, Mary, Queen of Scots , is choreographed by the company’s resident choreographer Sophie Laplane with an original score by Mikael Karlsson and Michael P. Atkinson. The result is a work of striking theatrical imagination and choreographic ambition. The ballet unfolds in the winter of Elizabeth I’s life. The ageing queen looks back on her turbulent relationship with her cousin Mary and the chain of events that ultimately led to Mary’s execution at Elizabeth’s command. Memory merges with imagination throughout the narrative. While the broad sweep of history remains intact, the work allows itself moments of poetic licence that deepen its emotional resonance. We first encounter Mary at the French court where she marries Francis II. His death leaves her estranged from her formidable mother-in-law Catherine and forces her return to Scotland. She is accompanied by the mus...
Full Details »

ABBA Voyage ★★★★★ ABBA Arena, Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park | Extended Run

Image
When great music from the past meets mind boggling technology from the future, the result is ABBA Voyage . This is a concert like no other. In a purpose built arena designed specifically for the show, massive high resolution LED screens, advanced lighting, and surround sound are used to create a fully immersive ABBA concert experience. Although the group’s last appearance in London was at Wembley Arena in 1979, they return technologically in this extraordinary production. These are not holograms or AI generated performances. This is a meticulously animated concert based on real performances by the band themselves. To achieve this effect, the group came together and re-performed their music using motion capture technology. They partnered with top visual effects experts to digitally recreate their younger selves. While the show includes a live band and backup singers, the Agnetha, Björn, Benny, and Anni-Frid seen on stage appear every bit as real as their original counterparts. One quick...
Full Details »

Double Indemnity ★★★ Richmond Theatre | March 3 - 7, 2026

Image
James M. Cain’s tale of murder and betrayal remains a classic of hard boiled crime fiction. Younger audiences may not remember Double Indemnity , Billy Wilder’s extraordinary film noir starring Fred MacMurray as the smart aleck insurance salesman drawn into a murderous scheme by the ultimate femme fatale, played by Barbara Stanwyck. In this stage adaptation, Tom Holloway has altered the names of the two central characters slightly, but their personalities remain recognisably the same. As the fast talking operator who is thoroughly outmanoeuvred by a seductive schemer, Ciarán Evans serves as both narrator and protagonist. For the most part he captures the stylised delivery associated with the genre, though there are moments when the performance tips from deliberate artifice into something that feels a little forced. The production also struggles with its central relationship. Mischa Barton cannot quite match Stanwyck’s glacial brilliance, and her seductive power and calculated manipulat...
Full Details »

Arcadia ★★★★★ The Old Vic | Jan 24 - Mar 21, 2026

Image
This splendid revival of Tom Stoppard’s masterpiece is definitely one of this year’s must-see productions. Intellectually demanding yet fizzing with wit, the play is brought vividly to life by a uniformly outstanding ensemble. Seamus Dillane is superb as the rakish tutor Septimus Hodge, delivering a performance of effortless charm and sly intelligence, while Matthew Steer is irresistibly funny as the mock poet/scientist and hapless cuckold Ezra Chater. Isis Hainsworth is luminous as the prodigy Thomasina, blending youthful grace with startling intellectual authority, and Fiona Button is deliciously bold as her mother, the gloriously predatory Lady Croom. Set in both the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, Arcadia explores how we confront death and search for meaning in our lives. Its title suggests Poussin's pastoral painting with the tombstone in its foreground, et in Arcadia ego . Faced with this existential problem, the play suggests two possible routes to understanding: scienc...
Full Details »

Bird Grove ★★★★★ Hampstead Theatre | Feb 13 - Mar 21, 2026

Image
Mary Ann Evans, better known as George Eliot, was a formidable and visionary writer at the heart of progressive intellectual circles in the nineteenth century. Bird Grove, the house her father purchased and where she lived with him before becoming the figure we recognise today, stands as a potent symbol of the social expectations he harboured for his daughter. Within its walls, she begins her measured, thoughtful rebellion against these constraints. In his play, Alexi Kaye Campbell offers a compelling portrait of a writer forging her identity. As her friend Mrs Bray anachronistically observes, she is finding her own voice. That spirit is captured by Campbell with striking sensitivity; Eliot is at once rational, principled and deeply compassionate. Bird Grove is a refreshingly intelligent play about emotionally intricate characters who must confront profound differences in their attitudes and beliefs, yet strive to do so with dignity and mutual regard. It feels worlds away from so many...
Full Details »

Samurai ★★★★★ The British Museum | Feb 3 - May 4, 2026

Image
“Samurai.” The word conjures images of fierce Japanese warriors in elaborate helmets with swords drawn, but this superb presentation reveals that there is far more to know about this class that came to dominate Japan’s political life and whose legacy still lingers in many aspects of contemporary culture. Structured in three sections, Rise of the Samurai AD 800 to 1600, The Long Peace 1600 to the 1850s and After the Samurai 1876 to the present , the exhibition demonstrates the importance of the samurai, both men and women, not only in warfare but also in the governance and cultural development of Japan. Bringing together more than two hundred and eighty objects from twenty nine lenders, the show offers a rich array of flamboyant helmets and intricate armour, alongside depictions of combat in scrolls by masters such as Hiroshige. There are also revealing glimpses behind the public image the samurai sought to project. Displays of smoking accoutrements, a popular pastime for both male and ...
Full Details »

Already Perfect ★★★ King's Head Theatre | Jan 9 - Feb 15, 2026

Image
In his 1934 book, the philosopher John Dewey argued that art is experience refined in the fire of imagination. This autobiographical musical traces the journey of young Matthew, who later becomes Levi, and tells the life story of its writer, composer, and leading actor, Levi Kreis. Raised in a rigid, fundamentalist Christian home that refuses to accept his homosexuality, and subjected to years of conversion therapy, Kreis is deeply traumatised by an upbringing marked by an absent father and an overbearing stage mother. The gifted musical prodigy will eventually win a Tony Award, but his unresolved emotional wounds lead him down a destructive path into drugs and adult film making. In this retelling of his story, Kreis confronts his younger self, sensitively portrayed by Killian Thomas Lefevre, and attempts to reconcile with his wounded inner child. He is assisted in this intense psychodrama by his sponsor Ben, portrayed with grounded warmth and quiet authority by Iffy Mizrahi. Like many...
Full Details »

The City Life Magazine | Reviews & Ratings