The Third Man ★★★★ The Menier Chocolate Factory | Jun 10 - Sep 9, 2023


This current musical adaptation of Graham Greene's novel, which became one of the acknowledged classics of the cinema, does a simply splendid job of creating the atmosphere of post-WWII Vienna which dominates the story. From the opening number we are brilliantly situated in Greene's world of disconcerting despair and moral murkiness. As Holly Martins, the writer of ethically simplistic cowboy novels who wanders into the web of deception inhabited by his friend, Harry Lime, Sam Underwood puts in a first-rate performance. His naïveté is palpable and his earnestness is endearing. We easily identify with the simplicity of his black and white vision of the world as it is challenged by the infinite shades of moral grey that make up his new environment. It is only Anna Schmidt, Lime's girlfriend, who brings some colour into this drab environment and lights Martins' world with a glimpse of self-sacrificing love. As the cabaret singer, Schmidt, Natalie Dunne brings a fine combination of hopefulness, loyalty and world-weariness to her portrayal of Lime's abandoned lover. The plot of the story is complicated, and sometimes the fidelity to the narrative might have been pared back to make it easier to follow. We also kept waiting for the blockbuster song which never appeared. The music is evocative, but it never achieves the significance of the unforgettable "Third Man Theme" which appears at a couple of points during the show. Paul Farnsworth's set and costumes are a triumph. Both succeed in intelligently setting and reinforcing the themes of the production without ever becoming obtrusive. Welcome to the beguiling world of the musical noir!

Rated: ★★★★

Reviewed by J.C.
Photo by Manuel Harlan

Want to save on tickets? See our Tips page.

When, Where, Getting there:

Most Popular

Stories – The Tap Dance Sensation ★★★★★ Sadler's Wells Peacock Theatre | Oct 23 - Nov 2, 2024

Garry Starr: Classic Penguins ★★★ The Other Palace | Oct 22, 2026 - Jan 3, 2027

Girls ★★★★ Young Vic | Oct 22 - Nov 21, 2026

Speculations ★★ Marylebone Theatre | Oct 30, 2026 - Jan 17, 2027

CADEL: Lungs on Legs ★★★★ Riverside Studios | Oct 13 - Nov 15, 2026

Catarina and the Beauty of Killing Fascists ★★★★★ National Theatre | September 19 - 26, 2026

Iphigénie en Tauride ★★★★ London Coliseum | November 6 - 14, 2026

Franz & Marie ★★ Charing Cross Theatre | Sep 28 - Nov 14, 2026

Golden Boy ★★★★ Almeida Theatre | Sep 8 - Oct 31, 2026

Triumph ★★★ Almeida Theatre | October 16 - 23, 2026

The City Life Magazine | Reviews & Ratings