Mimma – A Musical of War & Friendship ★★★ Cadogan Hall | February 28, 2022


It has been said that "in war, the first casualty is truth" but the second is probably trust, followed by friendship. Mimma – A Musical of War & Friendship looks at how the bonds of friendship and family are strained and sometimes broken by the pressures and divisions created by war. The theme is a powerful one but in this new work its presentation is obscured by the pacing and presentation of the narrative. Act I is a rather long introduction of the protagonist (Celinde Schoenmaker) and her circumstances as an anti-fascist activist in pre-WW II Italy. She is forced into exile in London where she forges a friendship with a nightclub singer (Louise Dearman). But even as she takes up this new life, trust has been broken to the point that she is under suspicion just for being Italian. For us, the use of a narrator (David Suchet) to explain many situations was sometimes intrusive and reduced the emotional impact of the story. There is also a problem with the arc of the narrative itself: some parts seem unnecessarily drawn out, while at other points we are rushed through events via an exposition that fills in too much of a complicated story. The subplot of Jacob Katz (Steve Serlin) and his art trafficking seemed an almost unnecessary add-on further muddling things. These issues aside, there is some absolutely glorious singing here. Elena Xanthoudakis as Ada Marini has a voice that completely enthrals. She commands the stage and the show reaches a new level when she sings. She is matched in that virtuosity by Ashley Riches. His portrayal of Mimma's brother was poignant and his voice was absolutely inspiring. "Aldo's Lament" was one highpoint as was the "Aria Pieta." Indeed, Act II has some absolutely sublime operatic moments which really overshadowed the rest of the show. The remainder of Mimma's journey simply seemed anti-climactic and it feels as though she never becomes the central character in her own story. Mimma – A Musical of War & Friendship chronicles a fascinating journey and there are some unforgettable moments, but there needs to be a refocusing that clarifies the narrative and its important message.

Rated: ★★★

Reviewed by J.C.
Photo by Danny Kaan.

Want to save on tickets? See our Tips page.

When, Where, Getting there:

Most Popular

St. Martin in-the-fields: Lunchtime Concerts ★★★★ FREE

Naked Boys Singing, The Garden Theatre at The Eagle - ★★★★ - Until October 25, 2020

The Last Caravaggio ★★★★ The National Gallery | Apr 18 - Jul 21, 2024 (Free Entry)

London Tide ★★★ National Theatre | Apr 10 - Jun 22, 2024

Howerd's End, Golden Goose Theatre - ★★★★★ - Until October 31, 2020

Calendar Girls ★★★ The Mill at Sonning | Apr 11 - Jun 1, 2024

Your Lie In April – The Musical in Concert ★★★★★ Theatre Royal Drury Lane | April 8 & 9, 2024

Player Kings ★★★★★ Noël Coward Theatre | Apr 1 - Jun 22, 2024

Foam ★★★★ Finborough Theatre | Mar 19 - Apr 13, 2024

The Comeuppance ★★★★★ Almeida Theatre | Apr 6 - May 18, 2024

The City Life Magazine | Reviews & Ratings