Jules and Jim ★★★ Jermyn Street Theatre | Apr 20 - May 27, 2023


On its publication in 1953 and with François Truffaut's subsequent film of 1962, Jules and Jim caused shock waves. Its presentation of the complex relationship between the three principals and their emotional and sexual web seemed extraordinary. However, with present mores the shock is no longer there and the characters now seem to be almost gender stereotypes. The original story is actually a meditation on three forms of love identified by the Greeks. The friendship of Jules (Samuel Collings) and Jim (Alex Mugnaioni) represents philia or brotherly love, while the relationship of both the men with Kath (Patricia Allison) is a tribute to the power of eros. And, as Jules delves deeper into his scholarship and an interest in Buddhism, he increasingly becomes a representative of agape. The challenge here is to bring the concepts to life and to make the representations of the three aspects compelling. Unfortunately, the decision to have most of the story recited in a declamatory style distances the audience from the characters, failing to engage the audience emotionally in the relationship tangle. Much of the discussion amongst the three principals is abstract enough, but the frequent stepping out of character to comment on the action breaks any thread of involvement. While the cast work hard to convey the deep connections between the characters they never quite ring true. The intensity of the friendship of Jules and Jim is the most emotionally real, while the erotic fascination with Kath seems a bit hollow. She may have an alluring smile, but her behaviour comes across as simply manipulative and attention seeking. The most difficult path to portray is Jules' transformation. Too often this can seem like a withdrawal from life, rather than an embracing of it. Achieving the larger than life proportions of a Greek tragedy is what is required here, and while this production has potential it doesn't fully realise its ambitions.

Rated: ★★★

Reviewed by J.C.
Photo by Steve Gregson.

Want to save on tickets? See our Tips page.

When, Where, Getting there:

Most Popular

Your Lie In April – The Musical in Concert ★★★★★ Theatre Royal Drury Lane | April 8 & 9, 2024

St. Martin in-the-fields: Lunchtime Concerts ★★★★ FREE

Player Kings ★★★★★ Noël Coward Theatre | Apr 1 - Jun 22, 2024

Naked Boys Singing, The Garden Theatre at The Eagle - ★★★★ - Until October 25, 2020

Life with Oscar ★★★ Arcola Theatre | April 2 - 20, 2024

Power of Sail – A Moral Thriller ★★★★ Menier Chocolate Factory | Mar 20 - May 12, 2024

The Last Caravaggio ★★★★ The National Gallery | Apr 18 - Jul 21, 2024 (Free Entry)

Opening Night ★★ Gielgud Theatre | Until July 27, 2024

The Comeuppance ★★★★★ Almeida Theatre | Apr 6 - May 18, 2024

Priscilla The Party! ★★★★ HERE at Outernet | Until September 29, 2024

The City Life Magazine | Reviews & Ratings