Desire Under the Elms ★★ Almeida Theatre | Nov 10 - Dec 23, 2026


Eugene O'Neill's Desire Under the Elms draws heavily on Greek myth, particularly the story of Phaedra, Hippolytus and Theseus. By setting a story of sexual passion, generational conflict and inheritance within the everyday circumstances of a New England farming family in 1850, O'Neill seeks to humanise the themes of classical tragedy and give the Greek conception of fate a modern resonance. Unfortunately, this current production fails to strike that balance. It seems intent on emphasising the archetypal nature of the work and does so through exaggerated performances in which characters shout and declaim their feelings. There is no real attempt at naturalism, and it is difficult to believe that these are real people in a recognisable situation. The Cabot family's New England origins also seem to have been lost: their accents suggest they have been transported to West Virginia, while the period in which the action takes place remains unclear. The production's uncertain sense of period extends to its rewriting of O'Neill's dialogue. Abbie's sexual innuendo about a screwdriver feels entirely out of place, as do phrases such as "mentally challenged" and "waste of space", which belong neither to the 1850 setting nor to 1924, when the play was written. The chemistry between Eben and Abbie, his father's new wife, is equally unconvincing. As played by Kelly Gough, Abbie is feisty rather than seductive, independent rather than a victim of her passions. From the moment she strides on stage in her anachronistic trousers, it is difficult to imagine her being swept along by desire or by fate. Other directorial choices prove equally distracting. Abbie suffocates the baby, yet her hands are covered in blood, an incongruity that draws attention away from the tragedy rather than intensifying it. The movement sequences dissipate tension rather than heighten it, while the music, intended to underline the emotions, simply hammers them home, robbing the production of any subtlety. Rather than allowing the characters' passions and conflicts to gather force and lead inexorably towards a tragedy that is both personal and epic, this production repeatedly spells out what should be left to the audience to feel. In its determination to make the drama larger than life, it loses the force of both the emotional complexity and the tragic inevitability at the heart of O'Neill's play.

Rated: ★★

Reviewed by J.C.
Photo by Marc Brenner

When, Where, Getting there:

Most Popular

Stories – The Tap Dance Sensation ★★★★★ Sadler's Wells Peacock Theatre | Oct 23 - Nov 2, 2024

Girls ★★★★ Young Vic | Oct 22 - Nov 21, 2026

Garry Starr: Classic Penguins ★★★ The Other Palace | Oct 22, 2026 - Jan 3, 2027

Speculations ★★ Marylebone Theatre | Oct 30, 2026 - Jan 17, 2027

CADEL: Lungs on Legs ★★★★ Riverside Studios | Oct 13 - Nov 15, 2026

Catarina and the Beauty of Killing Fascists ★★★★★ National Theatre | September 19 - 26, 2026

Franz & Marie ★★ Charing Cross Theatre | Sep 28 - Nov 14, 2026

Iphigénie en Tauride ★★★★ London Coliseum | November 6 - 14, 2026

Golden Boy ★★★★ Almeida Theatre | Sep 8 - Oct 31, 2026

Triumph ★★★ Almeida Theatre | October 16 - 23, 2026

The City Life Magazine | Reviews & Ratings